The History of Betty Boop, Popeye and The Power of Nostalgia

I’ll give it to him. Alan was on to something in episode 158 of the Lunatics Radio Hour podcast when he compared Popeye to a superhero. My first reaction was to laugh, but I was very quickly convinced that Popeye is really a superhero. Or at least his own version of one. He’s complete with superhuman, spinach powered strength, the tendency to stand up for those in need, a few arch nemesis, and a costume. 

Shortly after Alan and I recorded that episode, something strange happened. (Temper your expectations.)

I had tickets for July 16th to see Boop! The Musical (stay with me). But I woke up to an email a few weeks before our show date that the musical was closing on the 13th and our tickets were refunded. We decided to go anyway and got last minute tickets to one of the final shows. Generally, it was incredibly fun but I understand why it closed after only a few months on Broadway. But one side effect of the show was a new interest in Betty Boop and Fleischer Studios. 

Seeing the musical sparked a memory for me, but one that didn’t make sense to me in 2025. How and why did my sister have a Betty Boop lunch box back in the 1990s? What relevance or resurgence did Betty Boop, a comic from the 1930s, go through in our lifetime? And how was the character popular enough to sustain a musical, albeit a short-lived one, on Broadway in 2025? 

While researching the history of Popeye for this article, I came across a comparison between Betty Boop and Popeye, two of the most famous and beloved cartoons from the 1930s. Both characters that I organically interacted with in July 2025. Strange. If nothing else, at least a coincidence bizarre enough to warrant a deep dive. 

Popeye was first introduced to the world on January 17th, 1929 as part of the Thimble Theater comic strip. Thimble Theater was already ten years old by this time. He was created by Elzie Crisler Segar, an American Cartoonist mostly known as E. C. Segar. Segar died in 1938, but a group of writers kept the comic alive. In 1933, Fleischer Studios actually adapted Popeye into animation. Popeye continued to evolve as media did, from comic books, to movies and TV shows. The character and his side-kicks and enemies became incredibly popular. 

Betty Boop premiered less than a year after Popeye in 1930. Betty is a Jazz Age flapper, known for being chased around by men (literally) and hitting them on the head with flying pans. Later in the 1930s, Boop’s depiction was slightly un-sexified per the Hays code. At her peak, Boop was called the most popular personage on the stage. The first animated version of Snow White actually starred Betty Boop and was produced by Fleischer Studios. It was released in 1933, four years before Disney’s version. 

Both Popeye and Betty Boop use rubber hose animation, named for the way characters limbs move like rubber hoses. 

But here is the real point I am trying to make. While Popeye had a bit of a longer run and evolution than Betty Boop, both firmly still feel like characters from the 1930s. 

There was enough love for Popeye in the ‘80s to make a live action film starring Robin Williams and Shelly Duvall, and there was enough awareness to create a Boop musical on Broadway in 2025. Why? How?

There is something iconic and everlasting about these characters. We clearly saw them as kids because they were still on television, still had merch and lunchboxes being made, we were still being told by our parents to eat our spinach so we’d grow up strong like Popeye. I think a lot of this hinges upon the nostalgia of our parents. 

While there was less competition for characters this influential back in the ‘30s, it's still a sign of the power of children’s programming. There is nostalgia and comfort in cartoons. I’ve been obsessed with Scooby-Doo since I was a kid, and nothing has changed as an adult. Most of us probably grew up watching Looney Tunes cartoons, which also originated in 1930. And Disney films that date back to the ‘20s and ‘30s. There is real staying power for these bodies of work, despite the rapid innovation of the film and animation industries. I remember when I first realized how old some of these Disney movies were, Snow White (1937) for example. You don’t clock that as a young kid watching it. You fall in love with the stories, and by the time you’re an adult, they hold a special place in your heart. 

Here’s the final plot twist I’ll leave you with. Popeye’s first appearance in a cartoon was actually within a Betty Boop cartoon in 1933.